Plenty More Fish in the Sea

Story by Jeeves on SoFurry

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

There's always plenty more fish in the sea, but why go fishing when you've already found the catch of a lifetime?


This story was written for Todd Vulpine. It contains M/F sex between consenting adults, and incest. :3

Plenty More Fish in the Sea

Amantha gave a soft gasp as she heard a knock on her dorm room door. The vixen stifled a bashful giggle as she pulled her hand out of her panties and quickly closed the lid of her laptop. Rising from her desk chair, she padded over to the door and stood behind it, the paw that had been rubbing gently at her clit just moments before now resting on it's handle.

"Hey? Uh... who is it?"

The voice that answered was soft and smooth, but had an edge of frustration and annoyance to its tone. It was a voice the eighteen year old fox knew all too well. Her older brother, Todd.

"It's me, Ammy. Can I come in? Please?"

Without hesitation Amantha threw the door open, not even considering the fact that she was only wearing panties and a pale green spaghetti strapped top. Thankfully there was no-one else in the corridor but her sibling, and with a look of tender concern on her face the vixen reached out, grabbed him by one hand and dragged him into the room with her, closing and locking the door behind them.

By the time Ammy turned around, her brother was already sinking down to sit on the edge of her bed. He put his elbows on his knees, and buried his face in his hands with a growl of frustration. His sister sighed. She knew what was wrong. Todd had been out on a date with her again.

"What did that bitch do this time?"

It wasn't like Ammy to get so aggressive, particularly not someone who her brother was so obviously interested in, but the vixen couldn't help it. Todd had been on like four or five dates with this girl he liked, and every time he had come home more and more frustrated. God only knew what had happened tonight. It was only seven thirty, so unless they'd started their date early they couldn't have been together for more than an hour.

Sure enough, when Todd explained himself the reason for his despair seemed pretty clear.

"She said... she said that after dinner, we'd go back to her place and... w-well... goddammit. We got to the restaurant, and there were these friends of hers. Guy friends. She invited them to sit at our table with us. She was laughing at their jokes and touching them on the hands. I tried not to be jealous, tried to be cool about it. They were just friends after all. But then... then one of them whispered something in her ear. And... fuck. Fuck , Ammy. She looked at me, with those damn come get me eyes of hers, and said I should probably just go home, unless I wanted to watch them."

Amantha's eyes widened, and she smiled not with amusement, but sheer amazement at the heartless brutality of that whore her brother was so obviously distraught to have lost.

"What an absolute..."

Her voice trailed off for a moment, silently considering if what she was about to say was worth it.

"...cunt."

Todd lifted his head, eyebrows raised and unable to help smirking. Hearing his eighteen year old little sister say that word wasn't something he'd expected, not even as she rallied in defence of him.

"Yeah, I guess. But... I know it's dumb, but I can't help wonder. Is it me? Why do I keep ending up looking for girls who just want someone to have fun with until a bigger, hotter guy comes along? Why am I always the one who spends weeks chasing a girl, getting my hopes up and... a-and getting myself more and more worked up, only to end up blue-balled before we even make it to a bedroom together."

The male fox's sister didn't answer, at least not vocally. After a little while of them sitting in silence though, Todd's gaze falling back to the bedroom floor, he saw movement out of the corner of his eyes. Glancing up, the fox groaned softly. He watched as in one fluid motion his sister peeled off her top, no bra underneath revealing a plump set of breasts on her otherwise petite figure. Before he could do more than open his muzzle with a bashful whimper she was sliding down her panties too, stepping out of them and moving towards him, seemingly intent on straddling her brother where he sat on the edge of her bed.

"O-oh god. Ammy, I'm sorry. I... I didn't come here for this. I didn't mean I wanted to... I... I really just came to talk."

Amantha giggled as she sat on her brother's lap, naked and sliding herself forward until she could feel her bare crotch resting against his dark slacks. Already she could feel his cock beginning to stir, no doubt having already been active earlier in the evening, and now dragged back into action by the presence of her naked self. Wrapping her arms tenderly around Todd's back, the vixen leaned in and pecked him fondly on the lips, nuzzling him nose to nose as she whispered back at him reassuringly.

"I know. I'm not doing this because you asked. I'm not doing this because I think it's what you want. I'm doing this because what I need to do right now is to make my brother feel better."

Her cheeks flushed, and she growled in glee as bashfully, but with obvious delight, Todd's lips pecked back at hers.

"Besides. You're not the only one blue balled tonight. I was getting busy in here until someone decided to knock on my door and disturb me."

The vixen's brother shuddered. He looked at her, and as his own hands ran affectionately up and down her back he noted how stiff her nipples were, and how warm her crotch already felt against his.

"You were? Y-you're not just saying that to... to turn me on?"

Licking her lips, Ammy giggled once more.

"I'm not just saying it. I was masturbating before you interrupted me, Todd. So, if anything you being here right now isn't an inconvenience. It's exactly what I needed. Although, if me telling you about how I was watching clips of a guy jerking it in the shower on a hidden webcam while I slowly... slowly rubbed circles in my clit turns you on? I'm not complaining."

Todd snarled under his breath.

"God, Ammy. Don't tease me. Not tonight."

Again the vixen laughed, squirming and shivering with excitement on her brother's lap.

"I'm not teasing, Todd. I'm just trying to figure out how much longer it's gonna be before you throw me down on the bed, get those clothes off, and..."

Lowering her voice, Amantha leaned in close to her brother and whispered tenderly in his right ear.

"...fill your little sister with the cum that bitch ex of yours never deserved."

Ammy gave a happy squeal as her brother grabbed her roughly by the shoulders, pushing up off the bed, rising to his feet only to throw Amantha down where he had been sitting. She let herself rest where she fell, upper body resting on the bed and legs pushing her rump and tail up into the air towards her brother as he began to tear off his clothes just like she'd asked. With a giggle, the vixen wiggled her ass in anticipation. Ever since the first time she and her brother had succumbed to their urges and fallen into bed together, she had felt no regret. She knew Todd wasn't quite so at ease with the idea of their close relationship becoming sexual, but the number of times he had ended up letting loose in her presence was testament to the fact he couldn't possibly have been that against it.

The vixen's eyes bulged as she felt a strong pair of hands grab her hips, and just a split-second later felt the rampant, rigid heat of her brother's erection pressing itself to the warm, damp lips of her pussy. She buried her face in the bed beneath her, biting down hard on the sheets to muffle her scream as without any patience or foreplay, Todd delivered exactly what they both so desperately craved. His cock, an ever so slightly monstrous ten inches, drove into her with ecstasy, spreading Ammy wide open and stimulating all that her inner workings had to offer. His hefty balls slapped against her mound after just two strokes took him to the hilt inside her, and Todd's snarls of pleasure filled the room as he found himself with no method of muffling himself as Ammy had.

"S-she was... ahhh... texting me all last night. Getting me worked up with pictures and s-suggesting what she might do to me. Asking me to wait for today. To save it a-all for her. Bitch!"

The fox growled in desperate relief as he started to hump urgently at his sister's pussy, watching with delight as she writhed and shuddered beneath him. He saw her lifting her head from the sheets and turning to face him, jerking her neck sharply to one side as she moaned and whimpered pleadingly. Her wishes were obvious, and he obeyed right away. Already holding Amantha by the hips, her brother aided the younger woman in rolling over without once slipping off from around him. He groaned happily when she wrapped her legs around his waist, pulling him closer to the bed and reaching out with her now skyward stretching arms.

Leaning forward, Todd scrambled up onto the bed on his knees, pushing his sister up the length of her sheets until he was kneeling over her, the rocking of his hips intensifying once again as they gasped and blushed face to face.

"Forget her, Todd. Let her go suck all the cocks she wants. Let her get fucked by frat boys until she passes out. Tomorrow morning when she wakes up all ashamed and alone she'll still be a bitch. But you? You won't even care. Wanna k-know why?"

Amantha hissed and gasped to her brother as he fucked her, only keeping her cries of pleasure under control because between her attempts at talking and her gasping for breath there wasn't time enough for her to cry out too. She growled happily as he nodded, nuzzling down at her fondly and groaning as he picked up the pace of his thrusts once again.

"B-because... ahh... tonight you're staying with me. You're gonna fuck me till we both pass out, a-and then tomorrow morning... I'm gonna wake you up with the best blow-job of your life, and my pussy on your face. I'm gonna blow your mind and make you blow your load u-until... ohhh... until you can't even remember her name."

Biting her bottom lip, the vixen shuddered and blushed deeper still as her brother's sizeable cock hit a particular sweet spot inside her. She whined loudly, feeling her toes curl where they were wrapped tight around his ass.

"A-ahh... fuck. Besides, t-that bitch is an idiot anyway. Passing up on you? On... on this? Forget her, a-and just fuck me. Just like that, Todd. J-just... ahhh... y-you're gonna make me cum."

Todd's eyes widened. He snarled savagely and the force of his thrusting grew even more intensely passionate. All that his sister was saying was enough to drive him wild a thousand times over, but nothing could get him going and turn him on like hearing Ammy say that she was close to cumming. He knew it was wrong. Knew it was so bad of him to even be thinking this, never mind thinking it while balls deep inside his sister's clutching, convulsing pussy. But the fact remained, nothing any other woman could ever do for Todd even came close to the thrill he got from just the vague idea of his sister having an orgasm. And when that orgasm was as a direct result of his cock ploughing her? Todd now knew more certainly than ever that very soon indeed his blue balled situation was no longer going to be an issue.

The fox growled in desperate excitement as he felt his thick cock beginning to twitch harder and faster, and felt and saw Amantha writhing and squeezing all the more around him.

"I... I s-should... I should pull out..."

His face was flushed, his brownish red coat glowing pink in the cheeks. But Ammy was just as flushed, just as giddy with arousal as she nodded and giggled between loud, hungry moans.

"Of... aaah... of course you should. I'm... aaaahhh yes... I'm your baby sister, Todd."

Her moaning grew louder though, and the expression of giddy lust on her face even more intoxicatingly beautiful, as she whispered and moaned to her brother once again soon after.

"But... you won't. You won't pull out... a-aahhh, Todd. You'll knot me. You'll fill me. B-because you know it's not just what you want... it's what we want."

Just seconds later a deep and carnal shriek of joy escaped Ammy as the petite vixen not only felt her brother adding a new level of intensity to his thrusting, but also saw his eyes glaze over with that sort of feral passion that she had seen in him countless times before. It didn't just come moments before orgasm, though that was usually a part of it. It came moments before orgasming inside her. Almost like some unspoken, hidden fantasy even deeper than their incestuous longing for one another had finally been set loose and allowed to run rampant through Todd's mind.

What this fantasy was Amantha could only imagine. And imagine she did, frequently, up to and including this very moment as she felt her brother's knot beginning to flare and threatening to lock them together.

"O-oohh god, Todd..."

The vixen's eyes rolled back in her head as she felt herself losing control. She wailed mindlessly as her brother's knot grew to the point where it could no longer escape, and his thrusts became feverishly short and sharp as he humped in delirious ecstasy at Ammy's clutching, convulsing, and imminently cumming pussy.

"N-now, Todd. I'm... I'm cumming! Now! Cum, b-brother. Now!"

Ammy's cries were joined by Todd's own as with a snarl of final ecstasy, he obeyed his sister one more time. The two foxes howled and clutched at one another with frenzied bliss as they came, a burst of orgasmic wetness flooding around the male's cock from deep within his sister, but practically nothing compared to the force and volume of his own orgasmic ejaculations. Todd's howls and grunts of euphoria might have echoed around the room, but it was Ammy's piercing scream that won out above all else as she felt her body not just being sprayed, not just being filled, but being flooded by her brother's cum.

"Yes! Yessssss. M-more!"

The vixen wailed through her orgasmic rapture as Todd let loose his cum not in streaks or ribbons, but in torrents. It was obvious to Ammy that Todd's now ex date hadn't seen him jerk off or cum for her before, because if she had there was no way she would have passed up the opportunity to be with him. When it came to cum, there was no man like her brother. It's sheer volume was incredible, and the fact she could feel it sloshing and flooding deep inside her, so thick and warm and wet as more and more gushed from her brother's throbbing cock, made Ammy thrash and squirm and cum harder than ever around her sibling's glorious knotted erection.

"D-don't stop... please... don't... ohhh..."

Even when she knew her brother was spent, Ammy whined greedily. She gasped and grunted in pleasure as Todd attempted to give her exactly what she'd asked for, providing a few more half-hearted thrusts deep into her soaked and trembling pussy, and only when the expression on his face turned to strained, almost painful over-stimulation did she shake her head and whimper in understanding.

"A-ahh... oh... okay. Stop. You c-can... ahh... stop now..."

Ammy giggled as in his post orgasmic relief, Todd's tongue lolled out of its muzzle like a domestic dog's, and he licked at her own flushed and panting muzzle affectionately. Her giggle turned to a soft, happy moan when her brother whispered fondly into her ear, still breathless from his only just passed peak.

"W-what if... what if I don't want to... t-to stop?"

Shivering happily, the vixen smiled up at her sibling.

"Don't rush yourself. When you can go again, we will. I promise."

Todd's cheeks flushed darker. He shook his head.

"I... I don't mean right now. I mean... what if I don't want to stop... this. Coming over and... s-spending time with you like this. What if I stop pretending like it's not something I really... r-really love doing with you. And just... y'know... keep doing it? I know you've said in the past that you're always here if I want to fool around. But... would that still be true, if I did it more often?"

Ammy smiled up at her brother. Her arms were already wrapped around him, but she slid them up to rest around his neck, dragging his face down and fixing him with a deep, lingering kiss. Only when it had reached its natural conclusion, both of them having to break for air, did she answer.

"I know we can't be a couple. We both know that. We're not insane. But... Todd? I can't get enough of you. Of your body. Y-your cock. But also, just... you. Having you lying here in bed with me is like, the highlight of my day. And maybe that's wrong. Maybe it's messed up, but... I'm okay with that."

Still smiling, the vixen's eyes shone with joy as she continued to hold her brother in her arms while his cock twitched inside her, still dripping cum deep into her pussy as his knot locked them together.

"One day, I'll meet someone and maybe fall in love. I'm sure you will too. And when that happens, we'll probably have to stop doing this. But until then... I really am here, Todd. Not just every now and then. Not just after bad days or when one of us is feeling particularly needy or horny. I'm here for a cuddle. For a cosy blowjob while we watch a movie. For a quickie to keep me motivated while I'm working on an assignment. For... anything, really. Any day and every day. Just like I know if I come and knock on your door, you'll be there for me."

Todd whined bashfully, his own face glowing with delight and passion as he looked down at his beautiful little sister.

"D-dammit, Ammy... how did I get lucky enough to have a sister like you?"

Ammy blushed, giggling and squeezing Todd tightly in her arms.

"I don't know. But... I do know there are plenty more fish in the sea, and that one day you'll be lucky enough to find someone who loves you as much, and even more than I do. Until one of us catches that one though? Until we find that person worth hanging onto? Until you find that woman, or I find that guy who's worth giving you up? Lucky or not, you do have me. You always have me, however, and whenever you want me, brother."

By Jeeves

Like my stories? Want to see even more stuff well before it gets posted on SoFurry and get some extra goodies/stories for yourself? Consider supporting me on patreon! https://www.patreon.com/jeevesroo :D

The Competitive Edge

This story contains male masturbation, edging, and competitive fun between toooootally straight bros. ^^ It was written for Meesh with his kind permission to accompany a piece of his art. \<3 **The Competitive Edge** For some, college was all...

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comfy, Cosy, Warm and Wet

This story was written for Taki! It contains F/Solo masturbation and squirting. :3 **Comfy, Cosy, Warm and Wet** Taki giggled as she looked at herself in the bedroom mirror, the blue skunk admiring her plump naked body. She absently ran the...

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Let Slip the Cats of Lust

This story was written for Ikenna. It contains M/F incestuous sex between consenting adults. **Let Slip the Cats of Lust** '_Cry havoc, and let slip the dogs of war._' That phrase had been playing on Ikenna's mind a lot by the time he sat...

, , , , , , , , , , , , ,